Life Estate
What is a "Life Estate"?A
"life estate" is an estate whose duration is limited to the life of an
individual (usually the party holding the life estate), and a legal
arrangement whereby the "life tenant" during his or her life retains
use (the rights to rents and profits), possession of the property and
costs of maintaining the property. The life tenant cannot sell or waste
the property without the consent of the "remaindermen".
How is a Life Estate Created?
A legal life estate in real property can be created by conveying the
property by a deed which carves out the life estate for the grantor and
creates a "remainder interest" by which the "remaindermen" receive full
ownership (fee simple) immediately upon the death of the life tenant
(grantor).
What Are some Benefits of a Life Estate in a Personal Residence?
- The
life tenant has the legal right to remain in her house for as long as
she lives. Whereas, if she transferred her house outright, the new
owner could legally sell the property the next day forcing the previous
owner to vacate the premises.
- The property immediately passes to the remaindermen without the necessity of a probate proceeding.
-
A life estate is useful for purposes of Medicaid eligibility and protection from Medicaid recovery by the state as shown by the following example (Medicaid regulations vary from state to state; this example applies to New
York Law).
Jane Doe, a 69-year-old widow, owns a home in Westchester County, New
York with a fair market value of $250,000.00. Her home is her most
valuable asset which she wants to leave to her son. Jane has a
progressive illness which renders her ineligible for long term care
insurance. Therefore, she may have to apply for Medicaid as her health
declines. By drafting a deed which retains a life estate for Jane with
the remainder to her son, the following can be accomplished:
- For
Medicaid eligibility purposes, the transfer to Jane's son is not the
property's fair market value of $250,000.00. Instead the value of the
transfer of the remainder to the son according to tables used by the
Department of Social Services is .37914 of the fair market value of
$250,000.00 or $94,785.00. If Jane had simply transferred the house to
her son she would not be eligible to receive Medicaid until 36 months
from the date the deed is executed. By retaining a life estate, Jane
will be eligible to receive Medicaid after only 14 months have passed
form the date of the execution of the deed. (In Connecticut a similar
result is achieved using a slightly different methodology.)
- The New York State
Department of Social Services recognizes that a life estate is a
"limited interest in real property". Therefore, the state will not
require Jane to sell the property, nor will the state place a lien on
the property as a condition of paying a nursing home Medicaid for
Jane's care.
- Both New York and
Connecticut Medicaid laws and regulations limit recovery to probate
assets of the Medicaid recipient or her spouse (in our example Jane is
a widow). Since the life estate is extinguished upon Jane's death, the
property passes to her son out of probate and is therefore not
recoverable by the state.
- The
life tenant remains the owner purposes of real property tax
administration, and therefore continues to qualify for the STAR
exemption, veteran's benefits, and any other property tax reduction
available to the "owner" of the property.
What are the Tax Ramifications of Creating a Life Estate?
Pursuant IRC Section 2702 the gift tax value is the full value of the
property, without any discount. Therefore, in the above example for
gift tax purposes Jane transferred her home valued at $250,000.00 while
retaining a life estate. If the deed is executed in 1999, by April 15,
2000 she must file a federal gift tax return reporting that in the
transaction, she utilized $250,000.00 of her $650,000.00 federal gift
tax credit and a New York State gift tax return reporting that she
utilized $250,000.00 of the $300,000.00 New York Gift tax credit. She
would not have to pay any federal or state gift taxes as long as she
had not made other large gifts which previously used her federal and
state tax credits. (As of January 1, 2000, New York State gift tax laws
will be repealed).
If Jane lived in Connecticut, she would have to pay $10,500.00 of state gift tax based upon a gift valued at $250,000.00.
Are Life Estates for Everyone?
No. While a life estate can be advantageous in a Medicaid context,
individuals of larger estates with significant estate tax exposure
should consider other options, such as the Qualified Personal Residence
Trust. The life estate is only one of many estate planning and asset
preservation tools. It is important to consult with an attorney in your
state regarding Medicaid, real estate, tax, and estate administration
laws applicable to your personal circumstances.